This entry covers CLECA’s 2026 comments in CPUC proceeding R.25-02-005, the rulemaking to update and reform Energy Resource Recovery Account (ERRA) and Power Charge Indifference Adjustment (PCIA) policies. Track 3 is deciding which PCIA reforms the Commission will take up. CLECA’s members take both bundled utility service and service from Community Choice Aggregators and Electric Service Providers, so CLECA has a stake on both sides of the PCIA. The excerpts below are drawn from CLECA’s March and April 2026 comments on Track 3 scope and its July 2026 workshop comments.

Indifference has to work both ways

The utilities proposed a zero floor on negative PCIA rates, so departed customers would never receive a credit. CLECA opposed it.

The PCIA methodology should not guarantee that portfolio costs will always exceed market value.
If departing load customers are required to pay when the portfolio is above market cost, they must also receive the benefit when the inverse is true.
Reforms that reallocate risk in only one direction cannot be reconciled with the statutory standard set forth in Public Utilities Code Sections 365.2 and 366.2(d)(1) and applied in D.18-10-019.

Stable rules, not reactions to one year’s results

CLECA asks the Commission to keep recently adopted benchmark methods in place unless a real flaw is shown, and to phase in any changes going forward.

High or low MPB results are not necessarily evidence that the current calculation is wrong.
Accordingly, any proposed changes must be based on a methodological flaw that is clearly identified and supported by the record.
Considering the potential for rate shock to bundled and unbundled customers arising from this proceeding, any resulting changes should be adopted on a prospective basis ...

A real look at structural alternatives

CLECA supports examining alternatives to the current benchmark-based PCIA, including allocating PCIA resource attributes to each load-serving entity, at the same time as benchmark refinements.

Third, Track 3 should include a genuine evaluation of structural alternatives to the current PCIA framework, not merely refinements to market price benchmarks.
Consideration of an allocation framework should proceed concurrently with benchmark-refinement issues, because it could materially affect the need for, and scope of, those refinements.

Transparency for the customers who pay

Finally, the Commission should prioritize proposals that increase transparency into the PCIA calculations for community choice aggregator and direct access customer representatives, to ensure the process is verifiable and fair to all stakeholders.
Without that transparency, DA customers could bear their share of legacy-resource costs without knowing whether they receive the corresponding attribute value.

Read the filings

The excerpts above are drawn from CLECA’s filings in this proceeding. Read the complete documents:

Background: Direct Access and the PCIA exit fee.