This entry covers the October 9, 2026 rebuttal testimony of Sam Harper and John Holler in PG&E's General Rate Case Phase 2 (A.24-09-014), filed on behalf of CLECA, the California League of Food Producers, and the California Manufacturers and Technology Association. It responds to TURN's proposal to expand and reallocate PG&E's wildfire revenue category. The excerpts below are drawn from that testimony.

What TURN proposed

The testimony responds to a TURN proposal that would enlarge PG&E's wildfire revenue category and recover it from every customer on a flat per-kWh basis.

The Utility Reform Network (TURN) asks the Commission to direct Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) to expand its existing wildfire revenue category by two thirds, remove it from the distribution cost of service, and recover it through a non-bypassable public purpose surcharge allocated on an equal-cents-per-kWh basis.
TURN’s proposals would reduce the revenue allocated to residential customers by 4.6 percent while substantially increasing the amounts allocated to several non-residential classes.

A per-kWh allocation has no cost basis

CLECA, CLFP, and CMTA (the Large Ratepayers) argue that the proposal skips the cost-causation analysis a Phase 2 rate case is built on.

TURN proposes this reallocation without any marginal cost or cost causation analysis, and without explaining why kWh, unweighted by time, voltage, demand or load factor, bears any relationship to the costs it proposes to allocate.
Few, if any, of a utility’s costs are caused by unweighted kWh.

Routine vegetation management is ordinary distribution work

Much of the proposed expansion comes from relabeling long-standing distribution maintenance as wildfire spending.

It serves ordinary distribution safety, reliability, maintenance, and regulatory-compliance functions and predates PG&E’s WMP.
Its contribution to wildfire mitigation does not, by itself, justify removing its costs from distribution allocation.

Wildfire mitigation costs follow service voltage

The testimony explains why these are distribution-system costs, and why ignoring voltage would send the wrong signal to customers choosing how to interconnect.

A customer served at transmission voltage takes no distribution service.
Allocating wildfire costs without regard to service voltage tells those customers that the distribution system’s largest and fastest-growing cost does not depend on their selection of service voltage at the margin

Other customer classes face affordability pressure too

The Large Ratepayers do not dispute the residential affordability problem. They object to solving it at the expense of classes facing the same pressure.

What TURN’s testimony omits is that other classes also face affordability challenges, and seeking relief at those classes’ expense exacerbates those challenges.
From 2016 to 2025, PG&E’s average industrial power rates have more than doubled.

Data center concerns belong in the rate design rulemaking

TURN cites data center growth, but its allocator would land on existing industrial customers that are not data centers.

Anticipated growth in data center load does not explain why existing industrial customers should bear that additional share of wildfire costs.

What the Large Ratepayers recommend

The testimony asks the Commission to reject the expansion, keep the existing allocator for the category up to its 2024 recorded level of about $2.4 billion, allocate growth above that level by the voltage of the underlying work, and keep FERA costs in the residential class.

Proper cost causation and price signals work to constrain costs. Growing costs need accurate price signals even more desperately.
The remedy for growth beyond the negotiated range is to allocate the growth on cost, not to discard the negotiated result and allocate the whole of it on a measure blind to cost causation.

Read the filings

The excerpts above are drawn from the filings in this proceeding. Read the complete documents: