This entry covers the October 30, 2026 responsive stop-gap testimony of Sam Harper and Coleman Nickum on behalf of CLECA in PG&E's General Rate Case Phase 2 (A.24-09-014). It addresses PG&E's proposal to extend its Hourly Flex Pricing (HFP) pilots and redesign them as HFP 2.0. The excerpts below are drawn from that testimony.

CLECA supports extending the pilots

PG&E proposes to continue its Hourly Flex Pricing pilots through 2028 and redesign them as HFP 2.0 for 2029 through 2031. CLECA supports the extension and asks that the redesign work for large industrial customers.

Large industrial facilities can provide flexible load at scale, and HFP 2.0 will serve as the bridge between the current pilots and PG&E’s post-pilot real-time pricing rates. HFP 2.0 should therefore be designed to attract and retain large industrial participation.

Keep a subscription option for industrial sites

PG&E would eliminate the subscription for all participants. CLECA asks for a bilaterally negotiated subscription for Schedule B-19 and B-20 customers, or a submeter option for flexible load.

An industrial customer with firm load needed for safety, environmental compliance, and equipment protection would then have to choose between exposing its entire facility to hourly prices and not participating.
The subscription should be bilaterally negotiated between the customer and PG&E at enrollment, established by month and time-of-use period, and modified only by mutual agreement.

Let Base Interruptible Program customers participate

PG&E agrees that BIP and hourly pricing are complementary but proposes no rules. CLECA asks the Commission to adopt a double-compensation rule now.

HFP and BIP ask different things of customers. HFP allows each customer to decide whether and how much to respond to hourly prices, so voluntary load response will vary with market conditions and facility operations. BIP, by contrast, secures firm, forward-committed load reductions that customers must deliver when PG&E calls an event, with penalties for nonperformance.
The Commission should resolve these issues in this proceeding rather than defer them to the EDROIR or a future advice letter, as PG&E proposes.

Open the pilot to Direct Access customers

Direct Access customers can participate today only if their energy service provider signs an agreement with PG&E. CLECA proposes a path that does not depend on the provider.

The Commission should direct PG&E to offer HFP 2.0 to Direct Access customers on eligible rate schedules through a distribution-only option, with the hourly price applying to the distribution component PG&E provides, that does not depend on the customer’s ESP participating.

Preserve the hourly price signal

CLECA asks that non-marginal costs for large customers be recovered by scaling marginal prices (EPMC), consistent with the Commission's dynamic rate guidance, instead of a flat adder.

Fourth, PG&E proposes to recover non-marginal costs through a flat Revenue Neutral Adder (RNA), diluting the hourly price signal and departing from the Commission’s guidance in D.-08-049.
PG&E bases that departure on an analysis of the average residential customer that does not extend to large commercial and industrial schedules.

Why the design matters

CLECA frames the pilot as a test of whether dynamic pricing can work in California.

On the other hand, if the design discourages enrollment, retention, or meaningful load shifts, HFP 2.0 could become a counterexample, cited as evidence that customers will not enroll in or respond to dynamic rates, even though the cause was program design.

Read the filings

The excerpts above are drawn from the filings in this proceeding. Read the complete documents: