PacifiCorp, which serves roughly 46,000 California customers as Pacific Power, and the CPUC’s Public Advocates Office (Cal Advocates) have asked the Commission to approve a settlement that would suspend Pacific Power’s California energy efficiency programs effective January 1, 2027. The joint motion for the settlement was filed on August 21, 2026 in Application 25-09-016, and would reduce the utility’s public-purpose surcharge while shifting the company toward outreach about non-utility state and federal programs. Existing customer commitments would be honored, and PacifiCorp could pursue cost-effective programs again in the future.
Programs that stopped paying off
The move follows years of weakening results. The settlement records Total Resource Cost scores of 0.47 in 2023, 0.34 in 2024, and 0.76 in 2025, all below the 1.0 threshold at which a program returns more than it costs, and states the portfolio is “not forecast to be cost-effective over the next four year cycle.” The record shows that savings from the flagship Wattsmart Business program fell roughly 75 percent between 2022 and 2024, and that overall portfolio savings dropped about 40 percent in 2024 alone.
The settling parties framed suspension as protecting ratepayers. The agreement states that “suspending these programs avoids continued collection of ratepayer funds for programs that have not demonstrated cost-effectiveness.” Pacific Power’s Simon Gutierrez said that “delivering these programs in our California service area presents unique challenges,” citing a rural service territory averaging about four customers per square mile.
The issues behind the settlement
The settlement is the resolution of concerns Cal Advocates had raised about PacifiCorp’s program application. In its protest, Cal Advocates documented why the proposed portfolio did not justify continued ratepayer funding. The consolidated program scored a Total Resource Cost of 0.51 and a Program Administrator Cost of 0.49, only meager improvements over 2024’s 0.34 and 0.40, meaning ratepayers would receive back less than they paid in. Cal Advocates calculated that the application sought $7.18 million to save about 4 GWh over four years, roughly $1.80 per kWh saved, several times the $0.20 to $0.40 per kWh of comparable utility portfolios.
Cal Advocates argued that, amid California’s rate-affordability crisis, efficiency programs should return at least a dollar for every dollar ratepayers spend, and it questioned the plan to consolidate the programs into a single equity portfolio and to shift the Wattsmart Business program away from resource acquisition. It concluded that “these low cost-effectiveness scores indicate that the redesigned portfolio fails to deliver benefits that exceed ratepayer costs” and that the proposed program “will result in an unreasonable use of ratepayer funds.”
Rather than continue toward approval of a portfolio neither party could show was cost-effective, PacifiCorp and Cal Advocates negotiated the settlement to suspend the programs, end further ratepayer collection for them, and preserve the option to restore cost-effective programs if the economics improve.
Why it matters
Pacific Power is a small California utility, but the pattern is not unique to it: ratepayer-funded efficiency programs delivering steadily less while the bills keep arriving. It is the same structural problem CLECA has documented for California’s industrial efficiency programs, and a central reason CLECA has pressed for a performance-based redesign rather than continued spending on a framework that no longer measures up. See CLECA’s whitepaper on fixing industrial energy efficiency in California.
Sources: Utility Dive coverage; PacifiCorp and Public Advocates Office joint settlement motion (A.25-09-016); Public Advocates Office protest.