On October 30, 2026, CLECA filed testimony in PG&E's General Rate Case Phase 2 (A.24-09-014) on the future of the utility's Hourly Flex Pricing (HFP) pilots. PG&E proposes to continue the current pilots through 2028 and then redesign them as "HFP 2.0" for 2029 through 2031. CLECA supports the extension. The testimony, by Sam Harper and Coleman Nickum of Harper Advisory, asks the Commission to make four changes so the redesign attracts the large industrial load that can respond to hourly prices at scale.
1. Keep a subscription option
PG&E would eliminate the subscription for every participant. An industrial site has firm load it cannot expose to hourly prices, for safety, environmental compliance, and equipment protection. Without a subscription, that customer must put its whole facility on hourly prices or stay out. CLECA asks for a bilaterally negotiated subscription for Schedule B-19 and B-20 customers, set by month and time-of-use period, or as a fallback a separate submeter for flexible load.
2. Let Base Interruptible Program customers enroll
PG&E agrees that BIP and hourly pricing complement each other, but it proposes no rules and would leave the question to another proceeding. CLECA asks the Commission to decide it here, with a simple rule against double compensation: during a BIP event, the subscription resets to the customer's firm service level, and only reductions below that level settle at the hourly price.
3. Give Direct Access customers a path
Today a Direct Access customer can join only if its energy service provider signs an agreement with PG&E. CLECA proposes a distribution-only option, with the hourly price applying to the delivery service PG&E provides, that does not depend on the provider.
4. Preserve the price signal
PG&E proposes to recover non-marginal costs through a flat adder, which dilutes the hourly signal and departs from the Commission's 2025 guidance on dynamic rates. CLECA asks that Schedule B-19 and B-20 use equal-percent-of-marginal-cost scaling, which keeps the difference between cheap and expensive hours intact.
Why it matters
On the other hand, if the design discourages enrollment, retention, or meaningful load shifts, HFP 2.0 could become a counterexample, cited as evidence that customers will not enroll in or respond to dynamic rates, even though the cause was program design.
CLECA has made the same case in Southern California Edison's Large Power Dynamic Rate proceeding. Background: rate design and demand response.