On October 9, 2026, CLECA joined the California League of Food Producers and the California Manufacturers and Technology Association in rebuttal testimony in PG&E's General Rate Case Phase 2 (A.24-09-014). The testimony, by Sam Harper and John Holler of Harper Advisory, responds to a proposal from The Utility Reform Network (TURN) to change how PG&E's wildfire costs are defined and who pays them.

The proposal

TURN asks the Commission to expand PG&E's wildfire revenue category by two thirds, from $2.427 billion to $4.038 billion on 2024 recorded revenues, by adding routine vegetation management and other distribution work. It would then remove the category from the distribution cost of service and recover it from all customers through a surcharge set at the same cents per kWh for everyone.

Combined with TURN's other proposals, the result would be a 34.4 percent revenue increase for PG&E's transmission-level industrial schedule (B-20T), 17.4 percent for primary-voltage industrial customers, 16.7 percent for standby customers, and 11.8 percent for agriculture, alongside a 4.6 percent decrease for residential customers.

No cost basis

The testimony's central point is that the proposal comes without any marginal cost or cost-causation analysis. Annual kWh, unweighted by time, voltage, or demand, is not what drives wildfire mitigation spending. Those costs arise on the distribution system, and a customer served at transmission voltage takes no distribution service.

Proper cost causation and price signals work to constrain costs. Growing costs need accurate price signals even more desperately.

The testimony also shows that much of the proposed expansion relabels ordinary distribution maintenance. Routine vegetation management is performed across all of PG&E's overhead lines, predates the utility's wildfire mitigation plan, and was deliberately left in distribution rates in the last rate case settlement, which TURN signed.

A per-kWh charge works against electrification

Charging wildfire costs by the kWh raises the price of every additional unit of electricity, and that price is what a manufacturer weighs when deciding whether to electrify a process. The charge would be the same in every hour, so it would also blunt the price signals that reward using power when the grid has room and emissions are low.

Higher electricity costs can discourage industrial electrification and increase the risk that production ceases or migrates outside California, to jurisdictions served by higher-emitting grids.
That can discourage beneficial load shifting, industrial electrification, and investment in other decarbonization technologies.

Affordability is not only a residential problem

The Large Ratepayers do not dispute that residential customers face an affordability crisis. They point out that PG&E's average industrial rates more than doubled from 2016 to 2025, and that relief for one class at the expense of others facing the same pressure does not reduce costs. It moves them.

What the testimony recommends

  • Reject the proposed expansion of the wildfire revenue category.
  • Reject recovery through public purpose program rates on an equal-cents-per-kWh basis.
  • Keep the existing allocator for the category up to its 2024 recorded level, and allocate growth above that level by the voltage of the underlying work.
  • Keep the costs of the FERA residential discount program within the residential class, as PG&E proposes.

The same principle runs through the customer coalition's August letter on Wildfire Fund reform: wildfire costs are not caused by kilowatt-hours, and charging them that way falls hardest on the manufacturers California most needs to keep. The letter also makes the electrification point directly. It warns that a per-kWh allocation burdens the customers who have already invested in electrification, and that extending it to new Wildfire Fund costs would:

further increase the cost of marginal electricity consumption, discourage beneficial electrification, and weaken the competitiveness of California industry ...

Read the coalition letter (PDF)