AB 2182 (Irwin), the industrial energy efficiency bill CLECA sponsored this year, was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee on August 13, 2026 and did not advance this session. The bill had passed the Assembly 72–0 and the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee 17–0, with no registered opposition. The problem it was written to solve has not gone away.
Customers pay, and the programs underdeliver
California's industrial customers pay energy efficiency charges on every bill. Very little of that money comes back to industrial efficiency projects, because the programs measure savings against hypothetical baselines that do not match how real facilities make investment decisions. CLECA documented the problem in its whitepaper, California Industrial Energy Efficiency: Current Practice, Structural Problems, and a Simplified Alternative.
The evidence keeps accumulating
The clearest recent example is PacifiCorp. In August, the utility and the Commission's Public Advocates Office agreed to suspend its California efficiency portfolio after it scored 0.47, 0.34, and 0.76 on the Total Resource Cost test in 2023 through 2025. A score below 1.0 means customers paid more for the programs than the programs returned. That portfolio is small, but the pattern is not unique to it.
Reform the programs or end them
CLECA's position is simple. An efficiency program funded by ratepayers should return more than it costs, and the customers who fund it should be able to use it. Programs that cannot meet that standard should be redesigned so they can, and if they still cannot, the Commission should stop collecting for them. Continuing to collect for programs that do not pay for themselves adds to rates during an affordability crisis and buys little efficiency.
What comes next
AB 2182 was one route to reform, and CLECA will keep working the issue in the Legislature. The Commission does not need new legislation to act. It reviews efficiency portfolios and their cost-effectiveness on a regular cycle, and CLECA will press the same case there: fund what works, fix what can be fixed, and end what does not deliver.
More on CLECA's legislative work is on the legislation page.